U.S. push to further regulate ESG products in CAPs could hurt members
Staff | August 28, 2020 The U.S. Department of Labor is taking jabs at the inclusion of environmental, social and governance products in capital accumulation plans — and it could be to members’ detriment. In late June, the Department of Labor proposed new rules around ESG products in retirement accounts. “The proposal is designed, in part, to make clear that . . . plan fiduciaries may not invest in ESG vehicles when they understand an underlying investment strategy of the vehicle is to subordinate return or increase risk for the purpose of non-financial objectives,” noted a release from the department. However, a recent blog by Jennifer DeLong, head of defined contribution at AllianceBernstein, and Michelle Dunstan, the firm’s global head of responsible investing, said the regulations proposed could unnecessarily deter plan sponsors from offering ESG options. Read: CFA Institute proposing industry standards for ESG disclosure They noted the proposed rules aren’t a major shift from what’s already in place. “The new rules wouldn’t prohibit ESG options, but they could encumber the selection and monitoring process. For example, plan sponsors would need to do a lot more documenting to validate any ESG considerations on top of the current ‘all else being equal’ test. The rules would also all...