AI-to-AI Claims Settlement: Putting Claims Technology in Consumers’ Hands
By Joshua Schwadron, Founder & CEO, Mighty — The insurance industry is already using AI in claims. Personal injury attorneys are using AI in claims too. The real shift now is that now, for the first time, accident victims can use AI too after an accident—and that changes leverage, speed, and outcomes. At Mighty, we’ve completed the first motor vehicle injury claim settlements handled end-to-end by an AI agent, without a lawyer and without humans at Mighty involved in the negotiation. This isn’t a novelty. It’s the direction claims are headed: a consumer’s AI negotiating with an insurer’s AI to reach a fair number faster, with humans stepping in when a case is truly complex. The hidden problem: AI made law firms more profitable, not consumers better off Over the last decade, legal tech—and now AI—has been built mainly for personal injury law firms. The tools are real: automation for intake, records, demand letters, case summaries, negotiation workflows. But the economics didn’t change. Most firms in the United States still charge 33–40% contingency fees, and AI often just means they can run more files at the same price. So the consumer sees a weird outcome: AI reduced the cost of...